Replacing Elections with Drafted Representation
Image created with generative Ai.
Imagine this: no more political texts begging you for $25, no more yard signs littering your neighborhood, no more campaign ads that somehow make you hate both candidates equally. Instead, one day you open your mailbox and — surprise — you’ve been drafted to Congress.
Yes, drafted. Like jury duty, but with better snacks.
Why We’d Do It
Elections sound noble, but let’s be honest: they’re expensive popularity contests. Money buys megaphones, lobbyists buy access, and regular people get stuck with a government made up of career politicians who’ve mastered fundraising but long forgotten what it’s like to live on a normal paycheck.
In fact:
Congressional approval hovers around 20%, while incumbents still win reelection more than 90% of the time.
The average member of Congress makes $174,000 a year. The median American household income is about $83,700. That’s a pretty big gap.
Roughly 85% of Americans say politicians don’t care about people like them.
Only 22% of Americans trust the federal government to do the right thing most of the time.
So if government feels out of touch, it’s because it is.
The Draft System
Here’s the pitch: every year, Americans are randomly selected to serve in Congress for a limited term, like jury duty.
What you get if you’re drafted:
Competitive salary while serving (yes, you get the $250k).
Job protection when you return home.
Perks with staying power: tuition assistance, loan forgiveness, maybe even alumni benefits.
Support services: relocation, child care, elder care. No one should have to choose between serving and caring for family.
One term and you’re out. No campaigns, no dynasties, no lifers. Just a rotating cast of teachers, truck drivers, coders, nurses, ranchers, and retirees, all thrown together to hash out the laws of the land.
The Problems This Solves
Insider Trading: No more lifers quietly padding their portfolios. Short terms mean little time to game the system.
Lobbyists: Try cozying up to someone who’s back at their day job next year. Good luck.
Campaign Cash: If nobody runs for office, there’s nothing to fundraise for.
Representation Gap: Congress finally looks like America, not just America’s donor class.
Why This Isn’t Crazy
Ancient Athens used sortition (random selection) to fill many public offices. Modern “citizens’ assemblies” in places like Ireland and Canada have proven that everyday people can debate complex issues and shape real policy.
And remember: most elected officials already lean heavily on staffers. You think Senator Smith personally wrote that 800-page bill? Please.
The Benefits
Real Representation: A Congress that mirrors the demographics and financial realities of the nation.
Fresh Ideas: Everyday logic from everyday people.
Lobbyist Headaches: Influence networks crumble when the faces change every year.
National Pride: Serving becomes a civic badge of honor — not a punchline.
The Flaws (Yes, There Are Flaws)
Not everyone will want to serve. Some people will dread it, just like jury duty.
Not everyone will be good at it. But let’s be honest: that’s already the case.
Continuity could suffer. But career civil servants and staffers keep the machine running.
Training is needed. You wouldn’t throw a random group into open-heart surgery; there would need to be crash courses in lawmaking, governance, and ethics.
It’s not perfect. But it’s a big step closer to true representation than the system we’ve got.
A Different Kind of Government
Picture it: a single mom from Iowa sits next to a rancher from Texas, debating healthcare with a coder from Seattle and a nurse from Alabama. That’s not chaos — that’s democracy.
Maybe the problem isn’t that Americans don’t care. Maybe it’s that we’ve handed government over to professionals and told ourselves we’re too ordinary to matter. What if the opposite is true?
Maybe democracy doesn’t need more politicians. Maybe it just needs us.